Trinidad’s Finance minister says no to devaluation and going to IMF

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

The Trinidad and Tobago government on Monday said it has no intention of devaluing the local currency arguing that it would lead to increased inflation and “an immediate increase in imported goods.

In addition, Finance Minister Colm Imbert said that the seven-year-old Keith Rowley administration has no intention of going to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for assistance to further boost the economy.

Speaking at a news conference on issues arising from the IMF’s 2023 Article 1V review related last week, Imbert told reporters that any devaluation of the local currency would present hardship for the population.

From 1972 to 1976, the Trinidad and Tobago dollar was floated against the British pound sterling, however after 1976,it was pegged to the United States dollar. The first major depreciation of the Trinidad and Tobago dollar since June 1976 occurred in December 1985, when the country’s currency was devalued 50 per cent against the United States dollar.

In its latest report, the Washington-based financial institution said that it was encouraging the authorities here to continue “maintaining sound and consistent policies to support the current exchange rate arrangement.

“The Central Bank of Trinidad and Tobago (CBTT) has maintained its repo rate at 3.5 per cent since March 2020 to support the recovery of the economy. Increasing the policy rate should be seriously considered to contain inflationary pressures and narrow the negative interest rate differentials with the U.S. monetary policy rate,” the IMF said, adding “this would also help mitigate potential risks of capital outflows and reduce incentives for excessive risk taking that could threaten financial stability”.

Imbert told reporters that if for example the local currency had to be devalued at a rate of 10 to One “which would be a 50 per cent devaluation or a 40 per cent devaluation, you would have an immediate increase in the cost of imported goods and you would have immediate demands from the labour unions, which would be very difficult to challenge, for increased wages.

“This in itself would have…a domino effect on inflation,” he said, adding ” I think any serious person would know that if we devalue the dollar there would be significant inflation and it would send our people into poverty.

“I don’t think you need to do the maths for that, but if you would like me to do a mathematical calculation as to what the estimated inflation would be if we did a devaluation of the dollar by 40 or 50 per cent, I will ask the Central bank (of Trinidad and Tobago) to do that for me….”

Imbert maintained that “you don’t have to be a rocket scientist to figure out if you devalue the dollar significantly because we have a high import bill, because so many manufactured goods come from abroad, so much of our food comes from abroad and also you would have demands from the labour unions that there will be an inflationary increase that will be unsustainable. I don’t think we need to debate this point”.

The Finance Minister said that the government does not want to get into an IMF programme, given especially that the IMF is the lender of last resort.

“Countries go to the IMF when they can’t borrow from anybody else…so when they have nowhere else to turn, nobody will lend them money to balance their budgets and it is also a country in distress whenever a country goes to the IMF.”

He said countries with a “currency crisis” also go to the IMF, but in the case of Trinidad with an import cover of eight months Port of Spain does not have the problem of countries with at least one month or even a week cover.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Trinidad’s CCJ and CARICOM Secretariat formalize MOU

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

The Trinidad-based Caribbean Court of Justice (CCJ) has signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) with the Guyana-based Caribbean Community (CARICOM) Secretariat aimed at improving access and delivery of justice in the Caribbean region.

The agreement formalizes the partnership between the two regional institutions to execute several justice and legal sector projects funded by the European Union’s 11th European Development Fund (EDF).

The Secretariat will provide procurement support to the CCJ in the execution of several projects which form part of a larger project which also comprises work to benefit the Caribbean Community Administrative Tribunal (CCAT) and the Council of Legal Education (CLE). Implementing these projects is expected to have a transformative effect on justice delivery in the region.

The CCJ said that some of the more specific outcomes include a region-wide public education campaign to raise awareness of the Court’s Original Jurisdiction (OJ) which plays a critical role in the Caribbean Single Market and Economy (CSME) and protects the freedom of movement of people, goods, services, capital, labor, skills, and establishment guaranteed under the CSME.

In addition, the CCJ will also sensitize judicial officers and attorneys on the Court’s referral process so that national judiciaries are aware of their obligation to send issues concerning the rights under the CSME to the CCJ for judgment, when necessary.

The CCJ said that it is anticipated that increased knowledge of provisions under the Revised Treaty of Chaguaramas, which governs the regional integration movement, and avenues for redress will empower regional citizens to capitalize on their rights provided by the Treaty.

It said that the grant would also be used to upgrade the information and communication technology infrastructure in the CCJ courtroom to enhance the court user experience for litigants and attorneys.

CCAT, an impartial and independent judicial body responsible for hearing and delivering judgments on employment disputes from CARICOM institutions will also benefit from funds received under this grant,” the CCJ said in a statement.

“The Tribunal is a long-awaited development for employees of these organizations, as CARICOM institutions enjoy immunity from lawsuits brought in national courts and so, for many years employees did not have an avenue to challenge the legality of employment decisions.”

The CCJ said that through the revision of the legal education curriculum for the regional law schools under the CLE’s management, law students will also indirectly benefit from this EDF grant. The curriculum must be up to date to meet the emerging legal needs and trends within the Caribbean since most practicing attorneys in the region are matriculated by these law schools.

“It is anticipated that this collaboration will further strengthen the relationship between and among the various CARICOM institutions and the European Union,” the CCJ said, adding that it “welcomes this partnership and looks forward to the mutually rewarding benefits”.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Boat capsizes off St Kitts: One dead, 15 rescued alive, and search on for 16 missing persons, most said to be West Africans

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

A boat from Antigua capsized off the coast of St. Kitts, leaving one person dead, while 15 others were rescued from the choppy waters. Fourteen of these 16 persons are Africans.

Reports say the St. Kitts Coast Guard is now engaged in a desperate search for the other 16 persons who had been onboard.

It is said that the 30-foot vessel encountered difficulty some 12 miles east of St. Kitts, and a mayday alert went out sometime on Monday night, March 27.

Reports say it was a passing luxury sailboat that initially spotted the distressed vessel and lent immediate help to those persons holding onto the hull to keep afloat and battling the rough waves.

Other vessels have since joined the St. Kitts Coast Guard in the search for survivors, reports add. Coast Guard officials here have confirmed the development and say they are monitoring the unfortunate situation.

While some reports say the capsized vessel set out from Urlings, other sources tell REAL News that the boat – alleged to be The Osprey – is usually docked at the West Bus Station Fisheries Wharf and is owned by a national of the Dominican Republic.

There is speculation that the vessel – which carries two outboard engines – was on its way to St. Thomas in the United States Virgin Islands and was precariously overcrowded.

Late last year, hundreds of West Africans were brought to Antigua on chartered flights. Most were expecting to move on to other destinations and, ultimately, get to the United States.

However, this did not work out according to plan, and many residents were forced to conclude that Antigua had been used as a transshipment point in a migrant-trafficking ring.

Some of the West Africans left the country and actually made it to other Caribbean islands – only to be returned here.

Meanwhile, Sean Bird, the United Progressive Party (UPP) caretaker for St. John’s Rural East, has expressed grief about the development and is hoping that no more lives will be lost.

But Bird says he is not surprised that the West Africans would have made such a dangerous attempt to leave Antigua, since they desperately want to get to the United States for better opportunities.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

PM Browne’s statement on a boat tragedy which left Antigua and Barbuda illegally

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

The following Statement was issued today by Prime Minister Gaston Browne on a boat tragedy which left Antigua and Barbuda illegally:

“On behalf of my government and myself, I express deep sorrow at the loss of life and distress suffered by persons aboard a vessel which left Antigua and Barbuda illegally earlier today, Tuesday 28 March for an unknown destination, and which capsized in the open sea.

While reports are still sketchy, we understand that the majority of persons on board the vessel may be Africans who were part of those who arrived here as tourists but with the intention of migrating to other countries.

It is widely known that my Government has been making every effort to be helpful to these brothers and sisters from Africa who were marooned on Antigua, including by granting them residence and the opportunity to work. We have also been engaged with the United Nations High Commission for Refugees and the International Organisation for Migration on the best ways of treating them as refugees.

Two things appear clear from today’s tragic events. The first is that the Africans on board the vessel wanted to leave Antigua and Barbuda for another country. The second is that the owners and operators of a vessel in Antigua and Barbuda facilitated their transport on an illegal journey.

My government will launch a full investigation into the circumstances of this unlawful and dreadful affair, including the involvement of any citizens and residents.

We will also uphold our international obligations against human trafficking and illegal migration by strengthening our domestic institutions and enhancing our cooperation with regional and hemispheric partners.

In the meantime, my Government will also continue to offer refuge in Antigua and Barbuda to the survivors of today’s events, and we will make appropriate arrangements for the burial of the deceased. We will also make every effort to contact their relatives to advise them of this heart-breaking tragedy.

We appeal to the Africans, who are in Antigua and Barbuda, not to be tempted into any schemes such as happened today, but to work with the Government, through our Immigration authorities, to help find acceptable solutions to their circumstances.

All of the facts surrounding today’s calamity are not yet known.

However, I know that we all want to understand what occurred and to take action to ensure it does not happen again.

My Government will further advise of all these circumstances as soon as we receive more and better particulars.”

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Strengthening Caribbean Resilience Through Climate Action

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

Trinidad Cement Limited (TCL), a subsidiary of Cemex, S.A.B. de C.V. (“Cemex”) and the Caribbean Climate-Smart Accelerator (CCSA) announced in 2022 that they are working together in three key areas moving the Caribbean closer to resiliency and carbon neutrality.

The objective is to spur additional development in these areas including greening Caribbean cement products, exploring alternative fuels and promoting more resilient housing. The importance of this action cannot be understated as the region becomes increasingly vulnerable to the effects of climate change. Supporting the Caribbean in building resilience and identifying new solutions is an important step in canvassing wider industry support to reach climate commitments.

The CCSA was conceptualized after the 2017 hurricane season where hurricanes Maria and Irma decimated parts of the Caribbean. Since its 2020 incorporation the CCSA has unlocked opportunities to transform the region’s economy through sustainable development by identifying local innovations capable of building resilience, and matching them with adequate funding sources and support.

The CCSA has been involved in several regional initiatives to green construction including ongoing collaborations with CRDC Global and Partanna. This collaboration between CCSA and Cemex TCL will play an important role in helping the Caribbean region to become more climate resilient.

UNFCCC Global Ambassador in the Race to Resilience and Race to Zero and CCSA CEO Racquel Moses, stated “we are excited to collaborate with Cemex, they’re a regional and global leader who are actively demonstrating through “Future in Action” their commitment to climate action and our transition. Building our resilience and adapting to climate change is paramount. This collaboration with them, along with others addressing this most critical issue showcases our model of collaboration. The only way to pursue climate action is with all hands-on deck”.

Under its “Future in Action program”, Cemex announced a climate action target of a reduction of 47% of its CO2 emissions in cement by 2030. Additionally, the company set a goal for clean electricity consumption of 65% by 2030. These goals are the most ambitious in the cement industry and are verified by the Science-Based Targets Initiative (SBTi) according to the well-below 1.5?C scenario. Cemex expects these intermediate goals to assist the company in fulfilling its 2050 goal of being net-zero carbon in concrete.

“We continue to accelerate our commitment to become a net-zero CO2 company by 2050,” says Francisco Aguilera, Managing Director at Trinidad Cement Limited. “Exploring this collaboration reinforces our commitment and supports the region in building resilience and taking climate action for a greener, more sustainable Caribbean.”

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Moses: Latest IPCC report must spur more regional collaboration towards resilience-building

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

The executive summary of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Sixth Assessment Report (AR6) on Climate Change was released midway through March ahead of the unveiling of the full report.

An international body composed of the world’s leading scientists, the IPCC’s reports are seen as a synthesis of the scientific communities’ knowledge on key climate change issues, and are resource documents to inform policymakers at an international level. This report marked the final chapter in the AR6, with previous releases focusing on Physical Science (2021), Mitigation of Climate Change (2021), Impacts, Adaptation & Vulnerability (2022).

Emerging from the summary is yet another strong call to rapid climate action. The international panel continued to highlight the impact of fossil fuels and continued carbon emissions on the deregulation of the climate, and the need for countries to rapidly decarbonize by 2040.

The AR6 summary also noted the expected impacts on environments and natural resources like water under current models, all of which are expected to be impacted. Chair of the Alliance of Small Island States Fatumanava-o-Upolu III Dr. Pa’olelei Luteru said of the report: “While our people are being displaced from their homes and climate commitments go unmet, the fossil fuel industry is enjoying billions in profits. There can be no excuses for this continued lack of action.”

With several major policy decisions undertaken in the past few months including the operationalization of Loss & Damage, the goal to protect 30% of the world’s natural areas by 2030, and new legislation on the high seas – there is hope that more action may be forthcoming.

Speaking on AR6, Caribbean Climate-Smart Accelerator (CCSA) CEO and UNFCCC Global Ambassador Racquel Moses commented: “We must continue to work together to find solutions that work for our region. Resilience-building and adaptation are key tenets we must develop across the Caribbean, while continuing to exert pressure for rapid systemic change at a global level.”

The Accelerator was developed in response to the 2017 hurricane season and has the central objective to help transform the region’s economy by fast-track public and private investment opportunities that support climate action and economic growth through sustainable development. As a result, the CCSA has been actively promoting Caribbean solutions at major regional and international policymaking events, developing local innovations to remedy global issues.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Investment Needs of US$35 Trillion by 2030 for Successful Energy Transition

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

The global energy transition is off-track, aggravated by the effects of global crises. Introduced by IRENA’s Director-General Francesco La Camera at the Berlin Energy Transition Dialogue (BETD) today, the World Energy Transitions Outlook 2023 Preview calls for a fundamental course correction in the energy transition.

A successful energy transition demands bold, transformative measures reflecting the urgency of the present situation. Investment and comprehensive policies across the globe and all sectors must grow renewables and instigate the structural changes required for the predominantly renewables-based energy transition.

The Preview shows that the scale and extent of change falls far short of the 1.5?C pathway. Progress has been made, notably in the power sector where renewables account for 40 percent of installed power generation globally, contributing to an unprecedented 83 per cent of global power additions in 2022.

But to keep 1.5?C alive, deployment levels must grow from some 3,000 gigawatt (GW) today to over 10,000 GW in 2030, an average of 1,000 GW annually. Deployment is also limited to certain parts of the world. China, the European Union and the United States accounted for two-thirds of all additions last year, leaving developing nations further behind.

IRENA’s Director-General Francesco La Camera said, “The stakes could not be higher. A profound and systemic transformation of the global energy system must occur in under 30 years, underscoring the need for a new approach to accelerate the energy transition. Pursuing fossil fuel and sectoral mitigation measures is necessary but insufficient to shift to an energy system fit for the dominance of renewables.”

“The emphasis must shift from supply to demand, towards overcoming the structural obstacles impeding progress. IRENA’s Preview outlines three priority pillars of the energy transition; the physical infrastructure, policy and regulatory enablers and well-skilled workforce, requiring significant investment and new ways of co-operation in which all actors can engage in the transition and play an optimal role.”

The Preview warns that a lack of progress further increases investment needs and calls for a systematic change in the volume and type of investments to prioritise the energy transition.

Although global investment in energy transition technologies reached a new record of USD 1.3 trillion in 2022, yearly investments must more than quadruple to over USD 5 trillion to stay on the 1.5?C pathway. By 2030, cumulative investments must amount to USD 44 trillion, with transition technologies representing 80 per cent of the total, or USD 35 trillion, prioritising efficiency, electrification, grid expansion and flexibility.

Any new investment decisions should be carefully assessed to simultaneously drive the transition and reduce the risk of stranded assets. Some 41 per cent of planned investment by 2050 remains targeted at fossil fuels. Around USD 1 trillion of planned annual fossil fuel investment by 2030 must be redirected towards transition technologies and infrastructure to keep the 1.5?C target within reach.

Furthermore, public sector intervention is required to channel investments towards countries in a more equitable way. In 2022, 85 per cent of global renewable energy investment benefitted less than 50 per cent of the world’s population. Africa accounted for only one percent of additional capacity in 2022. IRENA’s Global Landscape of Renewable Energy Finance 2023 confirms that regions home to about 120 developing and emerging markets continue to receive comparatively little investment.

La Camera said, “We must rewrite the way international co-operation works. Achieving the energy transition requires stronger international collaboration, including collective efforts to channel more funds to developing countries. A fundamental shift in the support to developing nations must put more focus on energy access and climate adaptation. Moving forward, multilateral financial institutions need to direct more funds, at better terms, towards energy transition projects and build the physical infrastructure that is needed to sustain the development of a new energy system.”

IRENA’s World Energy Transitions Outlook (WETO) provides an energy transition pathway in line with Paris Agreement goals, limiting global temperature rise to 1.5?C. The forthcoming 2023 edition will contribute to the first Global Stocktake concluding at COP28 in the United Arab Emirates and will propose effective ways to accelerate progress over the next five years towards 2030.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

US lawsuit seeks to protect habitat of endangered corals

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service

An environmental group filed a lawsuit Monday accusing the U.S. government of failing to protect 12 endangered coral species across the Caribbean and the Pacific Ocean that have been decimated by warming waters, pollution and overfishing.

The Arizona-based Center for Biological Diversity said it filed the lawsuit against the National Marine Fisheries Service more than two years after the agency proposed to protect more than 6,000 square miles worth of coral habitat but never did so.

The critical habitat designation would cover 5,900 square miles off Puerto Rico, the U.S. Virgin Islands, Florida and the northwestern Gulf of Mexico. It also would cover 230 square miles around islands including Guam and American Samoa in the Pacific.

Such a designation could improve water quality in the coastal zone, limit excessive fishing and protect spawning grounds, according to the environmental group, which said “absent bold and immediate action” coral reefs worldwide could collapse over the coming century.

A spokeswoman for the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration Fisheries said the agency does not comment on litigation.

The Caribbean has five endangered species of coral, including the mountainous star coral, which is largely brown with fluorescent green streaks, and the pillar coral, which was moved from vulnerable to the endangered category in December. The other seven endangered species in the Pacific include the acropora jacquelineae, which resembles a flat plate that can grow up to three feet (1 meter) long.

Corals worldwide have suffered die-offs from pollution, diseases, acidification, over-fishing and an event known as “coral bleaching,” which is caused by warming oceans as a result ofclimate change.

Overall, 23 coral species, which are the building blocks of reefs, are listed as endangered and six as critically endangered, according to the International Union for Conservation of Nature.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Barbados Stock Exchange becomes a member of the United Nations Global Compact

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: Caribbean News Service
UN Resident Coordinator, Didier Trebucq and Managing Director of the Barbados Stock Exchange, Mr. Marlon Yarde (centre) are flanked by Leslie Gittens, Multi-Country Manager, United Nations Global Compact , and Tia Browne, Development Coordination Officer, Partnerships and Development Finance with the Resident Coordinator’s Office.

The Barbados Stock Exchange has joined the regional chapter of the United Nations Global Compact, the world’s largest corporate sustainability initiative.

To date, 20 regional companies have joined over 17,000 global counterparts in signing on to initiative spearheaded by the Office of the UN Secretary General. Global Compact supports companies to align their operations with sustainable business practices, with respect for the principles of human rights, labour rights, environmental responsibility, and anti-corruption.

Speaking shortly after becoming signatory to the regional body, Managing Director of the BSE, Marlon Yarde said joining the Global Compact was an incremental step that followed organically from their association with the United Nations’ Sustainable Stock Exchange Initiative (SSEI).

“This was a strategic move for the Barbados Stock Exchange, that only further reinforces our commitment to sustainability best practices. Now that we’re vertically affiliated with the UN’s sustainability arm, the BSE stands to benefit from broad and specific technical assistance and research that will allow us to champion sustainable and responsible business practices within our listed companies,” he underlined.

UN Resident Coordinator for Barbados and the Eastern Caribbean, Didier Trebucq, lauded the steps taken by the Barbados Stock Exchange in recognizing the value of the UN initiative and urged other regional businesses to follow suit.

“Just over one year since recruitment commenced in the region, the Global Compact Caribbean Network is growing steadily, and I remain very optimistic about its success. I am confident the Barbados Stock Exchange will gain significantly from its membership, and I encourage other Caribbean businesses to come on board as we collectively work towards building more resilient businesses in the region, in alignment with the Sustainable Development Goals,” he added.

Responsible for leading the ongoing engagement with the private sector, Global Compact Multi-Country Manager, Leslie Gittens, said having recognized that many businesses in Barbados had not yet heard of the Global Compact, they were “ramping up efforts to increase awareness within the business community of this important resource.”

“Participants in the Global Compact Caribbean Network benefit from opportunities to network with peers and experts in various industries internationally, regionally, and locally, through online and in-person events. The resources and guidance tools on sustainable business practices available to members are vast, and studies have shown conclusively how participating in the Global Compact has improved customer relations as well as profitability,” he concluded.

Donate At Caribbean News Service, we do not charge for our content and we want to keep it that way. We are seeking support from individuals and organisations so we can continue our work & develop CNS further.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com

Steely & Clevie Facing An “Uphill Battle,” But Have Been Strategic In ‘Dem Bow’ Lawsuit, Say US Attorneys

Black Immigrant Daily News

The content originally appeared on: DanceHallMag

 

Two US-based lawyers have offered their views on Steely & Clevie Productions’ copyright lawsuit against Panamanian artist and producer El Chombo, Puerto Rican artists Luis Fonsi and Daddy Yankee, and a slew of other Reggaeton artists, producers, and record companies.

Multi-platinum and Billboard-charting hits such as Despacito, Rompe,DuraGasolinaShaky Shaky, and Dame tu Cosita are among the 56 Reggaeton songs named in the lawsuit as having allegedly infringed on the Dancehall label’s 1989 riddim Fish Market (Poco Man Jam), better known as ‘Dem Bow.’

According to The Guardian, Gregor Pryor, a lawyer who specializes in media and entertainment, posited that Steely & Clevie “may be facing an uphill battle” if they cannot convince the court that “the defendant ever actually heard, or could reasonably be presumed to have heard, the plaintiffs’ song before creating the allegedly infringing song.”   

The attorney, who is not involved in the case, said that it is hard to prove that someone has had prior knowledge of a song, which means that the courts will have to consider a song’s popularity.

Nevertheless, he said that the use of language such as “foundational” and “iconic” in the Jamaicans’ lawsuit “to describe the instrumentals are early attempts to signpost its popularity and show that access would have been likely.”    

“Whether this point is successful or not will depend on the plaintiffs’ ability to demonstrate that the work was as popular as they have suggested, which may prove challenging,” he said.

Additionally, Pryor said that Steely & Clevie could also have to contend with the fact that the defendants have “a plethora of defences against copyright infringement at their disposal, which will make the plaintiffs’ argument more difficult to prove.”  

The lawsuit had initially comprised three separate cases, before they were consolidation into a single action in July 2022.

In April 2021, Steely & Clevie Productions’ made their first move when they filed a lawsuit against El Chombo and several other artists, producers, and record companies over their involvement in the release of Dame tu Cosita (which featured Jamaican artist Cutty Ranks) and the Dame Tu Cosita remix (which featured Pitbull and Karol G).

In October 2021, Steely & Clevie filed the second lawsuit against Luis Fonsi and several other artists, producers, and record companies over 10 of his songs, including Despacito (with Daddy Yankee) and the Despacito Remix (with Daddy Yankee and Justin Bieber).

In May 2022, they filed the third lawsuit against Puerto Rican rapper Daddy Yankee and several other artists, producers, and record companies over his alleged use of the Fish Market in 44 songs.

In March last year, the attorneys for Fonsi had responded to the copyright infringement lawsuit, pleading that they “have not engaged in any type of infringement,” that “there is no actionable similarity between the works at issue,” and by and large that they “deny knowledge or information sufficient to respond” to the majority of the allegations.

New York copyright lawyer Paul Fakler told the Guardian that Steely & Clevie has been strategic with their request for a jury trial.

“One of the key things in copyright law is that ideas are not protected, but unique expressions of ideas are.   So a lot of times when you have these copyright cases go to juries, you can get wacky results,” he told The Guardian.

Fakler also explained that when judges and juries “are faced with the intricacies of musical theory, the verdict often becomes less about the music and more about the story behind it”.

As a case in point, he cited the 2015 Blurred Lines case, in which a jury found Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams guilty of infringing on the copyright of a 1977 Marvin Gaye song, as a watershed moment in pop copyright claims.

In that case, according to an Ethics Unwrapped commentary by the University of Texas at Austin, Marvin Gaye’s Estate had won a lawsuit against Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams for the hit song “Blurred Lines,” which had a similar feel to one of his songs.

The University noted that in 2013, Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams had co-produced the hit single Blurred Lines, which earned them more than $16 million in sales and streaming revenues, and which had also been viewed hundreds of millions of times on YouTube and Vevo, and parodied numerous times.

“Despite its popularity, the similarity of Blurred Lines to Marvin Gaye’s 1977 hit song Got to Give It Up sparked controversy. The family of artist Marvin Gaye was outraged; they believed Gaye’s work was stolen. Thicke filed a pre-emptive lawsuit to prevent the Gaye family from claiming any share of royalties. However, Thicke also stated in public interviews that he was influenced by Marvin Gaye and, specifically, Got to Give It Up when he co-composed “Blurred Lines” with Williams,” the article stated.

In March 2015, the jury ruled in favor of the Gaye estate, stating that while Williams and Thicke did not directly copy “Got to Give It Up,” there was enough of a similar “feel” to warrant copyright infringement. Gaye’s heirs were awarded $7.4 million in damages, the largest amount ever granted in a music copyright case.

In September last year, British pop singer Ed Sheeran was ordered to stand trial in the US over claims his hit song Thinking Out Loud plagiarised the beat of Marvin Gaye’s Let’s Get It On, a track whose beat was also sampled in a remix of Shaggy’s megahit song, Mr. Bombastic in 1996.

The allegations were that Sheeran and his co-writer Amy Wadge “copied and exploited, without authorisation or credit Lets Get it on, including but not limited to the melody, rhythms, harmonies, drums, bass line, backing chorus, tempo, syncopation and looping”.

According to a BBC report, a judge had denied Sheeran’s efforts to dismiss the case, ruling instead, that the similarities between his song and that of the late Motown singer/songwriter’s, must be decided by a jury. 

Follow us for daily Dancehall news on Facebook, Twitter and Google News.

 

NewsAmericasNow.com